How this comparison works
Handmade sellers often compare Etsy marketplace fit against eBay resale demand. Fees are only one part of the decision, but fee math decides whether the order can support materials, labor and shipping.
Use this page for handmade and craft-product fee comparisons where the query is narrower than a generic Etsy vs eBay guide.
Platform Fees = Sale Price × Fee % + Fixed Fee + Extra Cost
Net Payout = Sale Price − Platform Fees
Profit = Net Payout − Product Cost − Shipping − Ad Spend
Winner = Platform with higher profit under your assumptions
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Etsy or eBay cheaper for handmade products?
Etsy is often cheaper on pure fees, but eBay can still win when the product gets stronger buyer demand or lower ad spend.
Should handmade labor be in product cost?
Yes if you want a stricter profit view. Add materials, packaging and a labor allocation into product cost.
Can I include promoted listings or Etsy ads?
Yes. Use the ad spend field for per-order ads and the extra rate fields for platform-specific percentage costs.